A place to share our evolving understandings of topics related to emergent literacy.
Sunday, January 18, 2015
Why Are Schools Using Only One Form of Assessment?
Whilst reading the chapter, it seemed to me that the greatest problem we have when it comes to assessment is that many schools are primarily only using standardized testing for their students. Perhaps that is not entirely the case, but it does seem that standardized testing scores are the only thing the “higher ups” are worried about. There are so many different ways that teachers can assess students such as portfolio assessments, oral assessments, and performance evaluation forms, which only scratch the surface.
It seems almost silly to me that we should rely almost solely on standardized testing results to assess our students, seeing as there are so many issues with standardized testing. From what I’ve experienced myself, to seeing my cadet students struggle with standardized testing, to what I’ve learned in other classes and in this chapter, it seems that there are more problems with standardized testing that positives.
One of the main issues of standardized testing that I’d like to focus on is pressure. There is loads of pressure piled on everyone involved with a standardized test. The students, the teacher, the administration, the parents. Standardized testing creates a high stress situation for all. Administration feels pressured to do well in the case where they might lose money or have to fire teachers if their students do not perform well on the tests. That could prompt them to put pressure on the teachers to ensure that their students perform well. The teachers feel pressured and then may be prompted to only teach the material to the test, neglecting so many other lessons and opportunities for learning for fear of losing their job if their students do not perform well. Other than the possibility of high test anxiety, students often feel extremely pressured by their teachers to do well on standardized tests as teachers often remind students how important they are. Parents also feel pressured by teachers and administration for their students to do well. This creates an extremely unhealthy environment for everyone.
So I ask again, why are schools only using this form of assessment as the one they take seriously? If so many other forms of assessment have proved to work, and will keep stress levels low, why not incorporate those instead of putting mass amounts of pressure on the students and the people who are there to help those students succeed?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree completely, the pressure from standardized testing is overbearing for most. It can lead to very unhealthy lifestyles such as: unhealthy eating, lack of sleep, and too much stress. I like that the chapter did point out the negatives to standardized testing and did not just overlook that it is just another way to assess. The pressure to do well in testing affects everyone in the school system and families throughout the community. Those in elementary school may not recognize the pressure yet, but those in high school feel the heat. The ACT and SAT are huge tests that impact students' future college careers. In 5th grade, its just another ISTEP day, which really means no homework.
ReplyDeleteTeachers and principals face a lot of pressure to do well on tests and that stress can eventually be felt by students. That negative influence may change the results of the test, which is why I think it is important for teachers to stay positive. Smile more and walk with a pep in your step because how you act is how the students will act. This pressure to do well is very overwhelming and I hope that someday that stress evaporates.
The part of the post where you discuss the pressure involved in standardized tests is one thing I think most people making the laws do not think about. The tests were created to gauge where students were academically but they have become so much more. It is something students and teachers stress about for weeks and months at a time. This environment is not helpful for students or teachers.
ReplyDeleteI do not understand why teachers now have to fight for their jobs through their students test scores. You can be the best teacher in the entire world but if you have a class of students that are incredibly behind or that have problems at home you are going to have unsatisfactory test scores. It just does not make sense to me!
I completely agree with you! Standardize testing puts so much pressure on students, teachers, administrators and parents. I have seen the looks on students faces when they don't do well on test and I have seen their anxiety when told about an upcoming test. They worry they will not move onto the next grade and their self confidence goes down. The pressure is overwhelming. Teachers are pressured because their salary and sometimes jobs depend on how well their students do on tests. School funding is determined by test scores. We are depriving our students of valuable knowledge because classroom time is dedicated to teaching "how to take a test". It just doesn't make sense to me!
ReplyDeleteThe main reason that states are relying so heavy on these tests is for the money. It is sad that today our education is not based on what is best for the student rather than how much money is involved. Any educator or pre service educator can tell you that standardized testing has more cons than it does pros, that is the majority of our discussions in class, deciding how we can best help students to be successful on these tests. School should be a positive and safe environment but it seems impossible to create that with the added stress and anxiety these tests cause for every one.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete