Conversations
are all around us. They started the day we were born and they have propelled us
to use language and grow our language skills. That is why I chose to focus my
post on that section of chapter four. Many people believe that elementary
students are too young to hold long book discussions or think deeply about a
text. If I child can hold a conversations they can hold a conversation about a
book. Teachers need to start using more forms of conversations in their
classrooms.
Try to think back to a time when you
were in school and a teacher “shushed” you when you were asking a fellow
classmate a question about academics. Even though you were probably asking this
question in at an inappropriate time teachers should not always shut down these
conversations. It seems like today teachers are focusing on worksheets or tests
instead of conversations. These worksheets take very low levels of critical
thinking and do not further a child’s critical thinking skills. Since
conversations are such a crucial part of language development why are so many
schools not using in their everyday classrooms? The book pointed out a few ways
to incorporate conversations into the lessons: small-group conversations with
the teacher, formal conversations without the teacher, inform conversations
without the teacher.
During small-group conversations teachers are only there to
help redirect conversations and they should follow the same rules as the
children. Formal conversations without the teacher can be tricky for a teacher
to handle because the classroom can be come loud and seem out of control. An
example of this is having literature circles where tall the teacher decided is
the students in each group and what book each group will be. It is up to the
students to pick the number of pages that they want to discuss and how the
conversation is directed. This builds so many skills that the students may not
develop will later in life. Educators may use this activity to promote
comprehension, as well as vocabulary skills. Literature circles may also
benefit students who lack confidence in their reading skills as they allow them
to have peer support to comprehend the material read. But most important of
all: English language learners (ELLs) are included in literature circles and
they have the opportunity to interact with English proficient students as they
model appropriate language skills. Informal conversations with out the teacher
may not be the conversation that are seen in the classroom as much but they are
seen during free-play periods, center time, or outdoor play/recess. Even
thought these conversations may not be “academic” they are still a very
important part of building social skills in school.
As a teacher do not feel like you have to have complete
control of your classroom all the time because you may not be allowing you
students to create conversations that will increase their critical thinking
skills. These discussions can also lead to topics and ideas that far exceed
anything that you could have prepared.
Great post Amy! I agree that allowing conversation within the classroom is extremely important. It allows for the students to interact with each other and grow with each other in language development, and since language development is not simply talking but also thinking, being able to expand those critical thinking skills are a great opportunity. It is sad that most teachers do not allow for those types of conversations to happen as often as they should. I feel that it may simply be because they do not know how they can help students actively develop their language development skills, but the example the book gave I feel are very helpful for all teachers. Especially for those teachers who are leery on letting all their students talk at once in small groups.
ReplyDeleteI loved reading this post. I agree that children do not need to always do worksheets. I think that they need to have those small group conversations or conversations in general. Those small group discussions deepen the thoughts of your students. It is always great to have those conversations, because you can always listen in to see what your students really do know that they have not been taught. It is interesting to walk around and here what different students think about different topics. I also agree that I do not think that you as a teacher should intervene with the conversations that your students are having unless you can ask a question that deepens their thoughts to have a better, more in-depth conversation. I also agree also you need to intermix ELL students with English speaking students, so they are around and interact with the English language. I also think that sometimes it is a good idea to have the ELL learners in there own group so that they can talk in their own language to each other, you do not want to take that away from them. You want them to feel included in your classroom, not excluded because they do not speak English. Make sure that everyone is included in the small group discussions.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed this post! It is very important to incorporate conversation within the classroom. The thing that always gets me with teachers who are strict, are the ones that say "If you have a question, ask your neighbor first, then me." But then the teacher yells at the students for talking in class. Furthermore, being able to communicate to your peers in class is essential to language development and social development. i like your connection to literature circles, and that the teachers role is to "redirect" the conversations when they get off track. Students should have the freedom to talk to their peers about their takes from the book. Sometimes it is the role of the teacher to stop and observe.
ReplyDeleteYou explained everything pretty well, and worksheets like we all have learned are the teacher curse words. I know as an Early Childhood teacher that conversations in groups is vital, and sometimes helps the class focus. I would hope that all teachers allow for time for each student to talk, whether it is at the morning five minutes before announcements, group time, talk to your neighbor time, or collaboration. All of those small things allow for students to get some ideas out, and begins the process of creativity within the classroom.
ReplyDeleteAwesome post! I personally LOVE literacy circles. This is a great way for teachers to monitor and asses children, but yet let the children have their own time. This shows the children that the teacher has confidence in them to be able to comprehend the story and gives them a little freedom while doing so. I agree with what you said about how children may be discussing academics when we ask them to be quiet. Letting children discuss academics or school in general during class would be a benefit for them.
ReplyDelete